Tenney Mountain Pizza in Plymoutd

Very people oriented staff. Most pizza joints call your name or type of pizza. This is not one of those places. Asked how our Thanksgiving was and delivered our food to the table. It was a steady flow of people coming in. We will be back.

Great made to order food and even better service!! The very first time I went to Tenney Mountain Pizza the crew as a whole greeted me like I was a regular. And they were very busy, but not busy enough to not turn and give a smile and nod.That was three years ago and they are still fast with great tasting food and awasome service.Oh yeah and the steak bomb is crazy good!!

Most was good however 1 pizza was not cooked as they tried to rush all pizza for the same time.

Fantastic pizza and french fries!

I LOVE everything from here...except their pizza. Honestly, I always feel it needs about 4 to 5 more minutes of cook time. Otherwise, I'm a fan of pretty much everything else on their menu, including the BEST fried chicken. Yummmm!

Excellent taste and good price

Decent pie. Made it quick enough. Place looked clean.

Things have changed. The steak and cheese, steak like rubber. Drivers not having proper change which means you have to over tip. But even not having change at all???. this is not a rant and I will go back and then I will give another review.

Ok place to grab a quick bite. I do recommend dining in, the food taste better when its hot. Staff is friendly and nice.

Simple tasty greasy pizza and plenty of space to sit if you would like.

My bacon wasn't cooked as crisp as I like. Usually they do much better. Still a good place to eat on Tenney Mountain Highway.

Barely worth 2 stars. It's only saving grace is mediocre pizza. Subs are all bread no filling, can't call it's a cheese steak sub if it has no cheese.. Service is dismissing and disinterested as well. Too bad, it used to be a decent place. Stick to the other options in town.

Great prices. Great food. It is my go to pizza spot when I am in the area.

1 star for quick service0 stars for the price and lack of cheese. Way too expensive. It cost just shy of $30 for 2 large and divide this by 16 slices for ~1.85 per slice and mostly tastes like tomato sauce and very little cheese. No way. Sorry but this is not any good pizza for the money. You lost a customer.

Greek pizza was delicious!

Ordered a large cheese pizza and frys over an hour ago still haven't gotten it I called and the guy was just coming back from his dilvery to get mine to bring it to me that was 20 minutes ago not impressed

Pizza subs food in general and the people are awesome

Would have been able to review the food if the girl on the phone had taken me off hold to actually place my order. I called twice, was put on hold twice, for a total of 10 minutes. I could hear her continuing to help other people, but she or anyone else were apparently too busy to take my order. Not a good first impression.

Great food , great prices, the people are fantastic ! There ..😀

Great food and service! Food was hot and fresh and delicious!! First time there and will definitely be back!

First time in the area. We wanted to try some pizza and could not be hapoier with the pizza as well as the great people working here. Thank you for making our experience in New Hampshire that much more fun!

Good food. Nice variety to choose from on the menu. Looking forward to going back.

Great pizza. Have been ordering for years. Our family will NEVER EVER order from here again.We ordered 4 large pizzas to go. When our family member went to pick them up he had his mask on but not one person who worked there had a mask on. How can we ever ever trust this establishment to do the right thing when it comes to any public health issues. If I had gone to pick up the pizza I would have left. My family member paid.SHAME ON YOU!!!!!

It was good pizza. I loved how it had crunch. Very good

Decent service and decent pizza. Budget friendly prices.

Great sandwiches! Thank you! Fresh!!

Excellent pizza. Eating pizza outside of nyc is always is a risky business. This did not disappoint... rather surprising. Very good food and fast service!

Best pizza in the area I've experienced!

My boyfriend and I ordered fairly regularly from Tenney and have never been disappointed. My 3 stars is due to the fact they changed their hours, and are now not open when we usually want to order from them! They still advertise as late night food but close at 8:30... very disappointing, especially when this means we have to rely on the pizzerias downtown with all of the college students ordering from them. :(

Great food great value

Great food. Great service. Clean tables. Better life.

Tenney Mountain Pizza is my go to in the town of Plymouth. Excellent variety of sandwichs and pizza toppings. Calzones are a nice big portion that will challenge even the largest of appetites! Very personable staff that make sure to remember every part of your order, which helps me cause I seem to forget plates and napkins if I go anywhere else. Great location to order for group events and large gatherings. My employer orders from Tenney multiple times a week! Most menu items can't be beat on price anywhere else in town. Better price doesn't always mean better food but in this case it absolutely does! Wash everything down with a cold soda from thier large coca-cola selection!

Great food great service pizza 2020 style with 11 of us and 3 dogs!

I got here an hour before they say they close they were trying to close early and made us feel almost like we shouldn’t eat here but we drove 30 min for pizza the pizza is good the building is fine pretty old and not too clean the employees aren’t super friendly but they aren’t rude just normal

Pizza here is excellent. Great crust and just the right amount of toppings.

There house special pizza is my favorite pizza of all time!! And it's a great price too!

Far and away the best pizza in the Plymouth area. I would recommend dining in or picking up rather than ordering delivery as it seems a bit of a hassle for them. I am assuming they only have one or two drivers on any given day. Delivery is normally on time, but can fluctuate depending on the day and hour. Make sure to leave a tip for the drivers because they must be rushing around like crazy. Also the indignant reviewer who came in with 6 people an hour before closing clearly never worked customer service before.

They said delivery would be an hour. It was 20 min. Good thing I happened to just be hanging around.The pizza dough was way too soft/thin to lift under the weight of the cheese and pepperoni.Crust was good, and it did have good flavor.My wife said her tuna sub was 3.5☆, maybe 4.0☆.

Excellent crust and toppings. The best pizzaria pizza for miles, with lots of other yummy menu items -- calzones, fries, hot and cold sandwiches. Basically a take out place but you can eat in if you want. Haven't been in a while because I'm watching my figure! But if I wanted a pizza in Plymouth, that's where I would go.

Good pizza great people and fast service

I am very disappointed. We ordered a medium sized order, not too many things to write down, and we got charged for something that they never even gave us. When we called back, to tell them we didn’t get it, they told us we never ordered it, but the receipt says otherwise. I’m very disappointed in the way that they handled the situation.

I would give this place 5 stars about a year ago. I dont know what happened but the pizza just isnt the same. Sometimes i get it and it is soooo good. Sometimes i get it and i do not even want to eat it. I think it depends on the people that work that day. The salads are always delicious. For some reason, again, depending on the people that work, i can order the samething i ordered the other night and get charged more money for it. I tend to like when the guys are working over the femalea just because my food ends up tasting better and cooked better

Very good and very fast service

Great subs and friendly staff in a clean restaurant!

Ordered a pizza for take out, only bc our fav spot was overwhelmed with orders. Arrived to pick it up and waited in a line of 5 socially-distanced people, 2 of which (myself included) were wearing masks. Noticed that the ENTIRE kitchen staff were not wearing masks, clearly not concerned about this pandemic. Promptly left. Gross.

Top notch pizza. They have redefined meat lovers by putting more meat on their pizza than I have personally ever seen. So good and well worth stopping in.

Enjoyed pizza-nice cheese and sauce. Cheese steak was great too. Service timing was off, some of our meal came before the rest. Food though was amazing.

I love this pizza place. Staff is always so welcoming, they are true locals and they great atmosphere of go-to local pizzeria. Menu is extensive offering wide variety of pizza, subs and such, even gyros sandwich is on the menu. They offer delivery (area restriction), pick up or eat in. Decor of this pizzeria is quite modest, pizza tastes good, not the worst pizza and the best pizza, its just as expected. I would recommend to all.

Staff was friendly, pizza was hot with nice thin crispy but delicate crust. Just about perfect

The food is great but the staff is always very short and rude.